My post for today should have been different. See, there’s this really fun editor, Ellen Brock who has a blog and makes great videos about writing. Check her out! She has a feature called First Page Friday where you send her your first 500 words and she critiques them and posts them for her followers to critique. I submitted my first page of my novel From the After, a YA paranormal romance. I’ve been reading these posts for months now and felt pretty confident that my first page was so awesome it’d get at least a 4, probably a 5.
Okay, stop laughing. We all have those delusions of grandeur sometimes.
Seriously. At some point, I will learn. I will balance the line between thinking, “I’m so awesome” and “I totally suck at writing.” Ellen did not give me a 5 or 4. Nope. 2. Ouch.
So, let’s talk about rejection! Though this is technically a critique, when it’s coming from an outsider, and someone “in the biz,” it feels more like rejection. If any of my critique partners would have said these things, I would have taken it completely positively and, to be fair to myself, my pity and wallowing in this case was very short-lived. I’m getting used to rejection and it doesn’t hit me nearly as hard as it once did. I’ll just outline my process for you. It’s not right or wrong, it’s just mine, and hopefully it helps.
You can read everything Ellen said about my page here on her blog. And the thing is. No matter how much rejection can suck, it can also be extremely helpful! Nothing Ellen said was wrong. In fact, ask my friends who’ve gone through about 8076234 versions of my first paragraph with me. This scene has always bugged me and now I know why.
On the plus side, I am also fully convinced that Ellen is a wonderful editor. (Not that I doubted before, really.) Check out her editing services here. But this story has been through 6 beta readers, 7 critique partners, and an MFA workshop, and there are things she saw that no one else did. Shockingly, most of it was POV stuff, which I never thought was one of my bigger weaknesses.
Here was the progression of my thoughts after I read Ellen’s comments:
- These comments are so helpful!
- The story will be so much better because of this.
- I knew that scene was a problem. It always bothered me, and now I know why.
- Everything she said is so true.
- Geez, maybe I should hire Ellen before I send this thing out.
- Wow, maybe this story is much farther from being ready than I thought.
- Sigh, this story sucks.
- It’s never going to get published.
- Maybe I should give this whole thing up.
That’s as far as it got. I froze at that last thought. It’s a total lie. Well, the last 3 are. There was no way this pity party was going to continue, so I flipped the switch into recovery mode.
Here’s my 3 steps for Rejection Recovery:
- Contact Support
I texted one of my besties who is also a writer. We’re in the same MFA phase, trying to not suck, so I knew she’d get it immediately. My text went something like “I submitted my first page to an editor’s blog and she gave it a 2 out of 5 and totally ripped it. :( Having a I-want-to-give-up-moment.” Boo hoo, sad little me. Yeah, yeah. I’m allowed one second of self pity, aren’t I? Well, I got a very quick response to the effect of “NEVER GIVE UP! YOU ARE AMAZING! YOU’RE WRITING IS AWESOME! I LOVE YOU!” I laughed and even forgave her grammar mistake made mid-rush of enthusiasm. This is why you gotta have writers friends. They’re just awesome.
- Check the Manual
By this point, I felt much better and was mostly done wallowing. Just to remind myself that I’m loved by more than one close friend, I went for my automatic go-to. Enter THE PICK ME UP FILE. Da da daaa!Stewart O’Nan said, “The ones who make it in this business are the ones who don’t give up.” So, while we all need to learn as much as we can and improve and grow in our writing, the thing writers may need more than any other thing is a guide of encouragement. I’ve blogged about my Pick Me Up File before. It is the most important file I have, even though I accidentally deleted it while writing that post. (Luckily it was easy to rebuild. I now have backups.)
That file is full of encouraging words from various people who both know me and love me, but also who have never met me beyond a user name. It’s fabulous. So, I read through it for good measure.
- Hit Restart
This is the point at which I remember, I am not alone. All writers, even the most famous, most successful, most brilliant, have been rejected multiple times. They’ve been told to give up and that they have no business being a writer. They did not give up. They pushed forward and became better and better. And you can, too. And you should.As it happened, shortly after this, I watched an interview with Church Wendig on Sword and Laser. He said some profound things about rejection.
“Rejection letters are armor. They’re proof that you’re doing stuff. They’re battle scars showing that you’re doing this thing that you want to do.” – Chuck Wendig
Even Chuck has been rejected, and if he can support his family of three on his writing income after being told to give up on writing, then there is a chance I can make it, too.
So, thank you Ellen and all the others who have and will in the future, reject me. Thank you for the battle scars, for making my armor stronger, for strengthening my will to never give up. And Ellen, I’m saving up. I need this book to be amazing, and I need people who will help me make it that way, even if I have to pay a bunch of money to do it! :)
So bye-bye, yinz! Off to edit that scene with all my shiny new notes.